This week's picks

Some really good comics out this week and some comics I really, really disliked this week (looking over at you SECRET AVENGERS). So which three comics make up the list of the top three of the week? Well...look, I'm figuring that out.

Avengers Undercover 1
I thought this was a good issue, maybe even a very good issue, in and of itself. What elevates it to "top picks" status over, say, CAPTAIN MARVEL or X-FORCE (which, truth told, I think I probably enjoyed more as a book), is that I think it's setting up its own world so extremely well. I think it's often really hard to incorporate what came before either as a direct or indirect sequel and build another story with changed characters around it. I think that AVENGERS UNDERCOVER has already done a marvelous job at showing what these kids are up to and what they're up against for this series, which is an incredibly difficult feat for a first issue. Very rarely does a series world build so effectively in one issue. Of course, that comes with the caution label that reads "AVENGERS ARENA finished just a couple months ago and is fresh in my mind so maybe that's what has built the world more than this issue" but I think you could come into this book without having read AVENGERS ARENA and still have a good sense of what's happening here. More impressively, I think you could come into this book knowing what happened in AVENGERS ARENA and not be plagued by over-excessive backstory and summarizing. That's particularly hard to do in the case of books that take such a huge shift, especially where so much tangibly happened last series. Good start to this one, really looking forward to how it shapes up.

Black Widow 4

Another new release week, another issue of BLACK WIDOW gracing the top picks list (get ready to see another familiar name on the top of the next entry). BLACK WIDOW is the kind of book that seems to have everything; writing, characters, plot, art, and colors. Everything is working on this series and, as Edmondson and Noto enter into Natasha's first arc of the new series, it seems like this is going to be more of the same. Normally when people say "more of the same" it's a negative, worrying that the book isn't trying anything new. WELL GOOD NEWS, this book is incredible already so "more of the same" is just "more of the doing great work" kind of thing. This one didn't get as much into Natasha's character as the last three did, though it works here because Edmondson clearly set out to establish her character in those first three issues and did a magnificent job of it. Getting us into story now is definitely a good way to go. Also, this book will find it hard not to make my top three every time if Phil Noto continues to absolutely bring his A-game in the art. Incredible and definitely able to carry a subpar book anyway. Fortunately, this isn't a subpar book.

Hawkeye 17

HAWKEYE has long been doing things unprecedented in mainstream superhero comics. The conceit of the book as a whole was that it would focus on the days when Hawkeye wasn't with the Avengers or whatever other team he may be a part of at the time. That means it was the daily life of a superhero with no powers while he set up his DVR or bought tape or watched a holiday special. With this most recent issue, these are all things he's done in this series, and done to tremendous effect. This issue finds Clint falling asleep watching a wintertime holiday special and dreaming of said special which happens to mirror his own thoughts on things and his own situation. He denies help from everyone repeatedly but they refuse to be sent away and, as a result, he and the others overcome the problems. Will this message translate to Clint's life? Probably not. He's kind of stupid. But it's a wonderful book and it's one that's incredibly well-done with artist Chris Eliopolous stepping in for series regular David Aja and providing exactly the right style of art and the right feel for the book (as well as expert colorist Jordie Bellaire stepping in for series regular expert colorist Matt Hollingsworth). I talked a lot in my full post this week about how HAWKEYE has succeeded while trying all sorts of new things and things that, on paper, absolutely should not work, so I won't recount it all here (just click that link above, guuuyyyys) but all of that is part of why this book makes this list. Also because it's great.