Okay guys, time to get serious. Today shall be the QUICKEST OF QUICK HITS because it's the holidays and no one wants to read all these reviews. Let's hit it.
Fantastic Four 15
Fraction and Kesel (s) and Kesel (w) and Ienco (a) and Mounts (c)
The F4 are in that other dimension and trying to stop the bonding of Doom, Immortus, and Annihilus all while restoring their powers which were apparently toyed with by the F4 of this dimension. Everything in that respect sort of works out, things with the villains do not as Immortus gets Annihilus' powers and goes to kill Doom but then Doom flips it around and gets all of their powers.
Still a rather interesting story though one of the neatest bits about this storyline is also one of the most confounding. I find it extremely interesting that both FANTASTIC FOUR and FF are kind of doing the same story but evidently in different universes with slightly different outcomes and different ways to fight it. This book is uniquely able to do this sort of thing and it's a really cool idea but I think execution is a little lacking. The F4 side is a little boring and the FF side is a little obnoxious. I think it would be going better if it played it just a little more straight on both ends.
FF 15
Fraction and Lee Allred (s) and Lee Allred (w) and M. Allred (a) and L. Allred (c)
In this universe, Immortus didn't get so close as in the universe the F4 are in currently to achieving "annihilating conqueror" status. Instead, Doom seems to have done what Doom does and conquered there. The FF plan is complicated and presented in 12 rhyming parts and one not rhyming part. Robots controlled by the kids from a remote area attack Doom's lair and the replacement F4 show up to wail on Doom after he takes power before Scott shows up to finish the job.
This book has suffered, particularly since Fraction left, from tonal problems in that there's something of an incredibly serious threat going on and something of a tone-for-a-five-year-old going on. I think Fraction toyed with this a bit, giving the book a lighter feel and Mike Allred's art matched it wonderfully but he knew when to pull back and the way to bring it back to seriousness. It's a really hard spot to find and I don't really blame Lee Allred for not totally hitting it because he was kind of thrown into it and now wavers a little too much to the goofy side which makes coming back to serious particularly hard. As a result, this book gets a little intolerably cutesy and drags. Ah well. Still a cool idea, I suppose.
Showing posts with label allred. Show all posts
Showing posts with label allred. Show all posts
Saturday, December 21, 2013
Thursday, September 26, 2013
FF 12, Guardians of the Galaxy 6
FF 12
Fraction and Lee Allred (s) and Lee Allred (w) and M. Allred (a) and Laura Allred (c)
Scott is having his typical panic attacks over Cassie's death and over whether or not he should be the leader of these children. In addition, he now needs to contend with the fact that Alex and company have brought Maximus the Mad to the FF and he's teamed with Julius Caesar to conquer. The kids are dealing with their own issues as they try to help Adolf Impossible fit in, a task that has no easy answer. They explain to him that his father is a supervillain, which doesn't go over well, though eventually he bonds with Luna over some superhero shojo anime. That out of the way, we see what Maximus and Caesar, with the help of old John Storm, have been building; it's a portal meant to pull the true F4 back to Earth, to the excitement of the current F4 and the FF and to the extreme displeasure of the spying Dr. Doom. Of course, the portal doesn't quite work as advertised and everyone eagerly waiting (not Doc Doom, hanging with Immortus and Ravonna) is zapped away somewhere.
There's a pretty good story here (not dissimilar, it feels, to when they were suddenly zapped away by the Wizard not too long ago) though I think this might be a bit of a learning experience for new writer Lee Allred. You may have seen up above that Fraction had a hand in the story but writing responsibilities have shifted to Lee Allred, who is, I believe, the brother of artist Mike Allred and the brother-in-law of colorist Laura Allred. The transition isn't totally seamless but it feels good enough that, with some time, it might work really well. I don't think Allred's writing is bad here, just a little more openly jokey than we've seen. There are far more obvious laugh-lines than we're used to and far fewer kind of funny moments. Still, that's an adjustment that may come with time or it may simply be the new order for the show. That may be fine but right now it leaves the book feeling a little weird because it doesn't feel that different to Fraction's style so it's clearly not a break from the style of the book already, but it also feels a little different. It's a tricky road to navigate and I think it's a little bit finding its legs here, but overall not a bad issue by any means. Still some good character bits and some legit laughs and, as ever, solid Michael and Laura Allred art. I'll be interested to see how a full family book goes.
Guardians of the Galaxy 6
Bendis (w) and Pichelli and Coipel w/ Morales (a) and Ponsor and Svorcina (c)
Angela is in the Marvel Universe and there's still not much to tell about who she is, why she matters, and how she got here (aside from the Age of Ultron time rips that have impacted so very little of the 616 except for when people want it to and when they don't need to use time travel in a book). She and Gamora fight while Peter Quill meets with Thanos to talk about, you know, destruction and stuff. Thanos is pretty sure Earth will destroy the universe and it will definitely destroy itself. Starlord eventually leaves and joins up with Gamora, who has been joined by the rest of the team in the fight against Angela, and they successfully knock her down. It's not by any means an easy fight and it's only after the entire team gets in on it that they are able to subdue her. When they ask what she is, the Watcher shows up to say her name is Angela and that he can't say any more.
To this issue's credit, it feels like a lot more happens than actually does. It's a fight scene book; it's not uncommon in comics to have an issue more or less dedicated to good guy vs. bad guy for an entire issue with little more by way of substance. There's not necessarily much more you have to do in that case, though you always run the risk of carrying it on too long and alienating and/or boring people. Even the best fight scene can overstay its welcome. This one doesn't have too many problems in that respect and the fight is pretty interesting, at least. It also rather disguises the fact that not much more happens; the cuts between Gamora and Quill make it seem like there are more things happening though, as seems normal these days, the appearance of the Watcher (he kicks our book off in typical Watcher fashion as he spends a page explaining who he is and what he does, because his name doesn't give it away) kind of hurts the book again. In a book full of flying people and green ultimate fighters, the Watcher always stands out as ridiculous and more than just a little plot-devicey. Still, the book rolls mostly well enough, even if not a ton happens to advance the plot. You want to talk about plots that don't advance, wait til my next review, later tonight (suspense!).
Fraction and Lee Allred (s) and Lee Allred (w) and M. Allred (a) and Laura Allred (c)
Scott is having his typical panic attacks over Cassie's death and over whether or not he should be the leader of these children. In addition, he now needs to contend with the fact that Alex and company have brought Maximus the Mad to the FF and he's teamed with Julius Caesar to conquer. The kids are dealing with their own issues as they try to help Adolf Impossible fit in, a task that has no easy answer. They explain to him that his father is a supervillain, which doesn't go over well, though eventually he bonds with Luna over some superhero shojo anime. That out of the way, we see what Maximus and Caesar, with the help of old John Storm, have been building; it's a portal meant to pull the true F4 back to Earth, to the excitement of the current F4 and the FF and to the extreme displeasure of the spying Dr. Doom. Of course, the portal doesn't quite work as advertised and everyone eagerly waiting (not Doc Doom, hanging with Immortus and Ravonna) is zapped away somewhere.
There's a pretty good story here (not dissimilar, it feels, to when they were suddenly zapped away by the Wizard not too long ago) though I think this might be a bit of a learning experience for new writer Lee Allred. You may have seen up above that Fraction had a hand in the story but writing responsibilities have shifted to Lee Allred, who is, I believe, the brother of artist Mike Allred and the brother-in-law of colorist Laura Allred. The transition isn't totally seamless but it feels good enough that, with some time, it might work really well. I don't think Allred's writing is bad here, just a little more openly jokey than we've seen. There are far more obvious laugh-lines than we're used to and far fewer kind of funny moments. Still, that's an adjustment that may come with time or it may simply be the new order for the show. That may be fine but right now it leaves the book feeling a little weird because it doesn't feel that different to Fraction's style so it's clearly not a break from the style of the book already, but it also feels a little different. It's a tricky road to navigate and I think it's a little bit finding its legs here, but overall not a bad issue by any means. Still some good character bits and some legit laughs and, as ever, solid Michael and Laura Allred art. I'll be interested to see how a full family book goes.
Guardians of the Galaxy 6
Bendis (w) and Pichelli and Coipel w/ Morales (a) and Ponsor and Svorcina (c)
Angela is in the Marvel Universe and there's still not much to tell about who she is, why she matters, and how she got here (aside from the Age of Ultron time rips that have impacted so very little of the 616 except for when people want it to and when they don't need to use time travel in a book). She and Gamora fight while Peter Quill meets with Thanos to talk about, you know, destruction and stuff. Thanos is pretty sure Earth will destroy the universe and it will definitely destroy itself. Starlord eventually leaves and joins up with Gamora, who has been joined by the rest of the team in the fight against Angela, and they successfully knock her down. It's not by any means an easy fight and it's only after the entire team gets in on it that they are able to subdue her. When they ask what she is, the Watcher shows up to say her name is Angela and that he can't say any more.
To this issue's credit, it feels like a lot more happens than actually does. It's a fight scene book; it's not uncommon in comics to have an issue more or less dedicated to good guy vs. bad guy for an entire issue with little more by way of substance. There's not necessarily much more you have to do in that case, though you always run the risk of carrying it on too long and alienating and/or boring people. Even the best fight scene can overstay its welcome. This one doesn't have too many problems in that respect and the fight is pretty interesting, at least. It also rather disguises the fact that not much more happens; the cuts between Gamora and Quill make it seem like there are more things happening though, as seems normal these days, the appearance of the Watcher (he kicks our book off in typical Watcher fashion as he spends a page explaining who he is and what he does, because his name doesn't give it away) kind of hurts the book again. In a book full of flying people and green ultimate fighters, the Watcher always stands out as ridiculous and more than just a little plot-devicey. Still, the book rolls mostly well enough, even if not a ton happens to advance the plot. You want to talk about plots that don't advance, wait til my next review, later tonight (suspense!).
Wednesday, August 14, 2013
Fraction leaving Fantastic Four and FF after their next issues
Bit of new news coming in that I could probably wait til tomorrow to say since I'm planning to review F4 tomorrow but Matt Fraction will be leaving both Fantastic Four and FF after their next issues (F4 12, next after this week's, and FF 11). I have rather a lot of faith in Marvel and their ability to replace talent on books successfully but I won't act like this doesn't sadden me. The reason given, as is stated in the article above, is that Fraction is leaving because his schedule is too packed as is (particularly with Inhumanity and other books coming up from Marvel). Seems legit. It's still unfortunate. Fraction's run on both books have been truly great and both books have a renewed sense of fun and of self-awareness. Fantastic Four has really gone back to its roots (in a lot of ways) and has established itself again as Marvel's first family, really making the book about the family and the problems they have. I'll be interested to see where the book goes, though I don't entirely know what the plans are and how they'll be presented going forward. Christopher Sebela (I believe; the article reports it as Selba but I don't think that's a person) is co-writing F4 11 (reviewed tomorrow!) and Karl Kesel will step into the book afterwards. Meanwhile, Lee Allred will pick up the writing reins of FF for issue 12, making the credits to the few issues they're all on Allred (w) and Allred (a) and Allred (c). Weird, you guys.
Still, pretty sad about this. Fraction is a shining star in comics and it hurts to have him leave a book that's been so good under his watch, let alone two separate books. Happy to give him a break, though. I'll allow it. At least it's not Hawkeye, am I right?
EDITED TO ADD: Not totally sure about this bit of news either (a cursory Google didn't find me anything) but Mike Allred says he's at least on the book to issue 16 but also said that he's there until "it's intended conclusion." Is Twitter trying to tell us that FF is done after 16?
Still, pretty sad about this. Fraction is a shining star in comics and it hurts to have him leave a book that's been so good under his watch, let alone two separate books. Happy to give him a break, though. I'll allow it. At least it's not Hawkeye, am I right?
EDITED TO ADD: Not totally sure about this bit of news either (a cursory Google didn't find me anything) but Mike Allred says he's at least on the book to issue 16 but also said that he's there until "it's intended conclusion." Is Twitter trying to tell us that FF is done after 16?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





